The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) passed in late 2017 heralded lower tax rates for businesses and individuals. There were a few tax increases as well. The elimination of unreimbursed employee business expenses caused problems for sales people, truckers, entertainers and more, but was easily resolved with an accountable plan.
And then there is the most hated tax increase of all, the limitation of state and local taxes (SALT) deduction. While the standard deduction did increase, the SALT deduction limited to $10,000 caused many taxpayers pain, especially in high tax states.
Before the ink was dry states offered up plans to circumvent the SALT deduction limit. The IRS shot each attempt down in order. The new tax rule was in place and states could do little to provide tax relief for their taxpayers. Even so-called low tax states heard from disgruntled taxpayers. The pain was felt widely.
But that has changed for some taxpayers.
Partnerships, S corporations and LLCs treated as such are pass-through entities. For years states have assessed tax at the entity level for non-resident owners of pass-through entities. In those situations a tax payment is made at the entity level and the member or owner gets a credit on their state taxes for the payment made by the entity. This is not considered an actual tax payment by the entity, however; it is considered withholding on the profits, distributed or not.. The entity does not get a deduction; the taxpayer does on their personal federal tax return if they itemize and are not over the new SALT limit.
The idea several states came up with was similar to the required withholding on profits for non-residents. They proposed allowing entities to pay the actual state taxes at the entity level, which allows a deduction on the entity’s federal tax return, without consideration for the $10,000 SALT limit on personal tax returns. In effect, the taxes paid at the entity level are in addition to whatever SALT deduction a member has on her personal federal tax return. Like the tax withholding on profits, the tax payment would be a credit on the state tax return of the entity’s member.
The best part is the current IRS interpretation allows taxes paid at the entity level to be deducted by the entity on it’s federal income tax return. This isn’t a perfect solution to the SALT deduction limits, but it helps taxpayers in states where the pass-through entity tax has been enabled.
Seven states (Connecticut, Louisiana, Maryland, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Rhode Island and Wisconsin) have passed legislation allowing pass-through entities to pay their tax at the entity level as of this writing and more are considering it.
We will briefly review the laws for each state that has legislation allowing for taxes to be paid at the entity level. This is a state level tax issue so the rules will be different between states. Once we complete our review we will turn to strategies to maximize this new tax benefit. There are a few instances where a taxpayer might not want to make the election to pay their state tax at the entity level. But many more taxpayers will want to use this new tax strategy even if they do not itemize or are affected by the SALT limits and even if the SALT limit were removed.
We will start with the author’s home state of Wisconsin and progress from there.
The Wisconsin pass-through entity program is elective and is available to S corporations and LLCs treated as such effective January 1, 2018 and for partnerships and LLCs treated as such effective January 1, 2019.
- The tax rate for entities making the election is 7.9%. Note that this is higher than the individual tax rate (7.65% in 2020) and may not always be the best course, depending on the situation of each owner on their individual tax return.
- To make the election over 50% of owners of capital and profits must consent. The consent is required annually.
- The election must be made on a timely filed return (by the due date, plus extensions).
- Revoking an election must be done by the due date, plus extensions.
- Income taxed by other states do not count unless also taxed by Wisconsin.
Wisconsin has multiple credits available to businesses which can require some adjustments to the pass-through credit and income on the personal tax return. The benefits of taxing income at the entity level can be significant, but for some businesses it can be a complex calculation on Wisconsin returns. Here are more detailed rules from the Wisconsin Department of Revenue for S corporations and partnerships.
Connecticut is the first state to enact pass-through entity tax legislation and is mandatory for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2018. This applies to sole proprietors, partnerships, S corporations and LLCs.
- Connecticut uses a multiplier which reduces the value of the credit.
- Connecticut has modified this multiplier to further reduce the value. The state’s actions indicate that this is considered a tool to raise revenue from businesses whenever the state desires. There is no reason to think Connecticut will not continue reducing the multiplier to the state’s benefit. Since it is mandatory there is no way for businesses to avoid the increased tax bill.
You can read more about Connecticut’s pass-through tax here.
Louisiana’a pass-through entity tax is effective for tax years beginning after January 1, 2019 and covers S corporations and all partnerships, except for entities filing a composite partnership tax return. The pass-though tax allows electing entities to be taxed as a C corporation.
The election for a pass-through entity to pay tax as a C corporation must be made in writing by the the 15th day of the fourth month following the end of the tax year. Then election can be made in the preceding year as well. Electing and revoking the election requires partners or members with over 50% of ownership consenting.
Shareholders and owners may exclude this income from their personal Louisiana return as long as the entity filed their corporate tax return properly.
The pass-through tax is calculated on a graduated scale:
- 2% for income from $0 to $25,000
- 4% for income from $25,001 to $100,000
- 6% for income over $100,000
Maryland passed entity pass-through tax legislation May 18, 2020. The law is effective for tax years beginning January 1, 2020 and after. Detailed regulations on the legislation are still forthcoming as of this writing.
The Maryland pass-through tax works similar to the other states where the state tax is paid at the entity level and deducted on the entities federal return without consideration for the SALT limits on personal tax returns. The pass-through tax rate is set at the top marginal tax rate for individuals, plus the lowest applicable county tax rate or the corporate tax rate for corporate owners of the pass-through entity.
Some additional issues to consider:
- Regulations will probably require the deduction be added back on the personal return to be allowed a dollar-for-dollar credit.
- The maximum tax allowed by the entity is capped at the distributable cash flow level of the entity.
In New Jersey pass-through entities can elect to pay the Business Alternative Income Tax (BAIT). Pass-through entities for tax years beginning on January 1, 2020 or after with at least one least one member liable for New Jersey income tax can elect to pay the BAIT. This applies to S corporations, partnerships and LLCs with 2 or more members. The tax rate is graduated with rates from 5.675% to 10.9%.
Facts to consider with the New Jersey’s BAIT:
- No retroactive elections allowed.
- The election must be made by the 15th day of the third month following the close of the tax year and must be made annually.
- All members must consent to the election or by a member authorized to do so (officer or manager).
- Revoking the election must happen by the due date of the tax return, excluding extensions.
- The credit by electing the BAIT can not reduce the individuals tax below New Jersey’s minimum tax. Unused credits are carried forward up to 20 years.
Oklahoma enacted legislation allowing the pass-through entity tax for tax years beginning on or before January 1, 2019. Once again sole proprietors and disregarded single member LLCs are not included. S corporations, partnerships and LLC electing to be treated as such are included in the Oklahoma legislation only.
The type of member determines the tax rate and is based upon the highest tax rate for the type of member:
- 5% for individuals (the highest 2020 tax rate), and for corporations
- 6% applies, the corporate tax rate.
- The election is made by filing Form 586 and can be filed in the preceding year through two months and 15 days after the close of the tax year.
- The election is binding until revoked.
- To revoke the election fill out Part 2 of Form 586.
- The election revokes any election to file an Oklahoma composite return.
- Oklahoma is similar to Louisiana in that a credit is not provided to the member. Members instead subtract items of gain and add items of loss on their personal return, the opposite of what happened on the entity’s state return.
Details involving the pass-through entity tax for Rhode Island include:
- Effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2019.
- Eligible entities include S corporation, partnerships, LLCs, trusts and other entities not taxed as a corporation for federal tax purposes.
- The tax rate is: 5.99% for individuals in 2019 and 2020 (the highest individual rate), but lower than the 7% corporate rate.
- To make the election Form RI-PTE must be filed by the 15th day of the third month following the tax year.
- With the election the pass-through entity will not be required to comply with non-resident withholding.
- Member receives a tax credit.
- Rhode Island does not address revoking the election.
Applying the Pass-through Entity Tax
As you can see by the details of the states that have some form of pass-through entity tax that the rules vary widely between states. Many use a credit to pass-through the benefit while others adjust income on the member’s personal tax return.
Many considerations need to be taken into account. Even if the SALT limit were eliminated there would still be instances where the pass-through entity tax would be beneficially to entity members. Even if you don’t itemize there can be a tax benefit as the entity’s state taxes are now deductible on the entity’s federal return, giving the member the state income tax deduction before it hits their federal income tax return, plus the standard deduction.
There are also reasons not to make the election (except in Connecticut where it is mandatory). The pass-through entity tax can affect the Qualified Business Income Deduction, Earned Income Credit, Saver’s Credit, Premium Tax Credit and more.
The tax professional preparing the entity income tax return and that of all the members will have an easier time determining the best course of action.
Let’s use Wisconsin, my home state, as an example. Most taxpayers in Wisconsin are currently paying 6.27% tax on their top dollar with high incomers paying 7.65%. The pass-through entity tax is 7.9% and is treated as a credit on the individual tax return. However, if there is no other income for the individual it is possible to create a larger tax than necessary.
If all members can deduct the state tax attributable to the entity without hitting the SALT limit it probably does very little good to make the election while making the tax returns involved more complex. Likewise, those hit by the SALT limit and even those who do not itemize will normally get otherwise unrealized value.
Special attention has to be taken as it affects other areas of the tax return. The amount of state tax paid by the entity is deducted on the entity’s federal tax return. This will lower the value of the Qualified Business Income Deduction in virtually all cases.
Using Wisconsin again, electing the pass-through entity tax can increase complexity of the tax return on the entity and individual returns. If, for example, the Manufacturer’s Credit is taken, adjustments need to be made on the Wisconsin personal income tax return. Manual calculations will be required.
There is a balancing act with this tax strategy. It appears many, even most, members of pass-through entities will benefit from the pass-through entity tax. However, the cost to prepare the returns will undo some of the gain and the loss of tax credits or deductions elsewhere on the return might make this a less appealing tax strategy.
There are numerous small businesses where the complexity will not be an issue and the benefit will effectively side-step the SALT limitations. Complex returns will require a seasoned tax professional. Talk to your accountant! Determine if the pass-through entity tax will lower your taxes and what it will take to prepare the return with the election. The pass-through entity tax is probably here to stay regardless where future federal tax laws go. And for those holding an interest in a pass-though entity it can add to serious tax savings.
More Wealth Building Resources
Worthy Financial offers a flat 5% on their investment. You can read my review here.
Personal Capital is an incredible tool to manage all your investments in one place. You can watch your net worth grow as you reach toward financial independence and beyond. Did I mention Personal Capital is free?
Medi-Share is a low cost way to manage health care costs. As health insurance premiums continue to sky rocket, there is an alternative preserving the wealth of families all over America. Here is my review of Medi-Share and additional resources to bring health care under control in your household.
QuickBooks is a daily part of life in my office. Managing a business requires accurate books without wasting time. QuickBooks is an excellent tool for managing your business, rental properties, side hustle and personal finances.
A cost segregation study can reduce taxes $100,000 for income property owners. Here is my review of how cost segregation studies work and how to get one yourself.
Friday 17th of July 2020
Great article. Highlights an area of the tax code that isn’t well known. I think it’s good you’re bringing attention to these areas of the law law.
As someone who prepares a lot of CT and R.I. returns I find CT’s law to be burdensome to very small businesses. The taxes are required to be paid regardless of the amount of tax owed and you have to pay it electronically or you are penalized. Which puts older business owners at a disadvantage. I think it’s a great planning opportunity for certain businesses , but i just wish they kept in mind the smaller family businesses that don’t have the resources to keep up with the complexity.
Mr. Hobo Millionaire
Thursday 9th of July 2020
Informative post, Keith. Nice "Survivorman" video, too. Haha. Beautiful property.