The risks associated with day trading extend beyond the actual investment. Before the trade is placed consideration needs to be given to the tax implications.
Profits and losses for day traders can be taxed under the rules for an investor, trader, mark-to-market trader or dealer. There are pros and cons to each method.
Facts and circumstances prevail. Yet, the rules are not always clear.
Investor vs. Trader
The factors you need to consider when determining if you are a trader or investor, include:
- Holding period.
- Frequency of trades and dollar amount of those trades.
- Does the taxpayer pursue the activity as a livelihood?
- Time devoted to the activity.
On the surface this may sound straight forward, but as Endicott vs Commissioner, TC Memo 2013-199 shows, it is not.
Endicott used a strategy of selling covered calls. He did not trade every day and usually allowed the options to expire.
Most people would consider Endicott an active trader. He had 204 trades in 2006 and 303 trades in 2007. The court concluded this was not substantial trading. However, in 2008, Endicott made 1,543 trades, which the court said was substantial.
Endicott had purchases and sales of around $7 million in 2006; nearly $15 million in 2007; and about $16 million in 2008. The court agreed these were all substantial amounts. But the court couldn’t keep it simple. They went on to say “managing a large amount of money is not conclusive as to whether a petitioner’s trading activity amounted to a trade or business.” The court is saying large amounts of money being traded is not enough. This is why tax professionals say “facts and circumstances” so often.
You can use this chart to help you make a determination for your situation.
Remember, these rules apply to taxpayers who buy and sell securities or commodities only. These rules do not apply to cryptocurrencies. The IRS considers all crypto as property. The SEC clearly states wash sale rules only apply to securities. This means wash sale rules do not apply to crypto. Significant tax-loss harvesting is possible as a result.
Tax Implications for Investors, Day Traders, MTM Traders and Dealers
The chart at the end of this post provides a guide on how taxes apply to investors versus day traders. The advantage of being a trader is the deductibility of margin interest and other business related expenses on Schedule C. Both investors and traders still face the capital loss limits, but traders get the additional deductions of related expenses and margin interest. (Long-term capital gains are taxed preferentially. As a trader, all the LTCGs get the favorable treatment while expenses can be deducted against other income, usually taxed at ordinary rates.)
(The capital loss limit allows the taxpayer to deduct losses of up to $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately) against other income.)
To avoid the capital loss limits you can elect to be a mark-to-market trader. Wash sale rules also do not apply to to MTM traders.
Dealers are required to follow MTM rules. (Dealers have a place of business where they engage in the buying and selling of securities for customers. )
A trader can elect to use mark-to-market rules [IRC Sec. 475(f)]. Most tax software has an elections page where you can check a box and the election is automatically populated.
- All securities gains and losses are treated as ordinary income or loss.
- Securities held at the end of the tax year are deemed sold at FMV.
- Basis of securities deemed sold at year-end are adjusted accordingly.
The biggest advantage of making the MTM election is to avoid the wash sale rules and to sidestep the capital loss limitations.
The MTM election can be revoked, but you must wait at least 5 years before you can elect again. Since the mark-to-market election has limits, you need to consider the election carefully.
Other issues to consider if you are thinking of making the MTM election:
- The MTM election must be made on a timely filed original return, without consideration for extensions, for the taxable year immediately preceding the election year.
- You can attach the election to a timely filed extension.
- You also must attach Form 3115 (Change of Accounting Method) if you do not make the election in your first year as a trader (Rev. Proc. 2019-43).
Investors, traders and MTM traders do not pay SE tax and earnings cannot be used to fund IRA/SEP contributions. However, a dealer does pay SE tax and can use gains for IRA/SEP contributions.
As you can see, this isn’t the easiest area of tax code to navigate. I strongly recommend you consult with a competent and qualified tax professional when dealing with the trader/investor classification and before you make the MTM election.
May all your trades be profitable.
More Wealth Building Resources
Worthy Financial offers a flat 5% on their investment. You can read my review here.
Personal Capital is an incredible tool to manage all your investments in one place. You can watch your net worth grow as you reach toward financial independence and beyond. Did I mention Personal Capital is free?
Medi-Share is a low cost way to manage health care costs. As health insurance premiums continue to sky rocket, there is an alternative preserving the wealth of families all over America. Here is my review of Medi-Share and additional resources to bring health care under control in your household.
QuickBooks is a daily part of life in my office. Managing a business requires accurate books without wasting time. QuickBooks is an excellent tool for managing your business, rental properties, side hustle and personal finances.
A cost segregation study can reduce taxes $100,000 for income property owners. Here is my review of how cost segregation studies work and how to get one yourself.
Thursday 17th of June 2021
Keith, just found your blog and I'm on a binge - love your content.
I had never heard of MTM until now. Question, can anyone (an individual who is an active trader, but does not trade professionally or manage other people's money) apply for the MTM classification? What are the downsides of doing this?
Does this rule of MTM "Securities held at the end of the tax year are deemed sold at FMV." imply that none of your gains would be taxed at the long-term capital tax rate?
Thursday 17th of June 2021
Kunal, mark-to-market is for traders only. That means you need to qualify as a day trader to make the election; active trading is not enough. You do not have to manage other people's money to qualify as a MTM trader.
MTM traders report gains and losses on Part II of Form 4797 instead of on Form D/Form 8949. All gains reported in this section of Form 4797 are taxed as ordinary income. If you are a trader it is unlikely there will be many, if any, LTCGs, as that would mean you are an investor, not a trader.
Friday 11th of June 2021
Your article implies interest expense is not deductible for an investor. That is wrong. Horrible writing. Bad professional.
Saturday 12th of June 2021
I made no such implication, Jim. Margin interest is deductible with limits. Day traders don't have those limitations as they deduct the expense on Schedule C. Plus, day traders get additional deductions on Schedule C. Plus, if the taxpayer has more than one Schedule C the margin interest can reduce SE tax. Facts and circumstance prevail, as always.
Don't read something not there into it.
Monday 7th of June 2021
Wow this is eerily timely. I’ve put a ton of time in & grown my humble trading account steadily over time to where I can daytrade freely (No PDT) where I’ve half looked this topic up before without much good intel. Thanks for the awesome content as always.
Monday 7th of June 2021
The more a topic comes up in the office the more likely I am to write about it.
Hope this post helps with your situation.